Curriculum · Mental Health / Psychiatry
Oppositional defiant disorder
What it is
Oppositional defiant disorder is a pattern of negativistic, hostile and defiant behavior toward figures of authority lasting at least 6 months. Held against conduct disorder it is mostly about attitude and disobedience: ODD opposes authority but does not harm seriously, while CD means criminal behaviors that violate the rights of others and social rules. All conduct disorder behaviors are illegal or very harmful.
How it presents
A described example is a girl of 10 brought to the office by her parents on the recommendation of the school counselor. For at least the past year, both at home and at school, she often loses her temper, is easily annoyed and is very touchy. She is sullen and angry, arguing frequently with her parents and teachers. At school she irritates and annoys classmates, then blames them when they react negatively toward her. She also disrupts the classroom by refusing to comply with classroom rules and expectations or with the teacher's authority. Set against the criteria, that pattern is toward her parents, her teachers and the teacher's authority, it has gone on for at least the past year, and nothing in it is illegal or very harmful. That is negativistic, hostile and defiant behavior toward figures of authority lasting at least 6 months, and it is not the criminal behavior that violates the rights of others and social rules.
The two features to hold from it are that the pattern shows itself toward authority, and that it does not cross into harm.
How it is diagnosed
The conditions to weigh in the differential are these.
- Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder: its inattention, hyperactivity and impulsivity may be mistaken as oppositional behavior. Its own criteria are five: first, symptoms present before the age of 12 years; second, they occur in multiple environments (at least 2, such as home and school); third, they interfere with or decrease quality and productivity of academic, occupational or social functioning; fourth, they are present for at least 6 months; fifth, they are inconsistent with the developmental level of the child. If the symptoms are only at home, then possibly oppositional defiant disorder or parental expectations; if only at school and not at home, then they may be an undiagnosed learning disability.
- Childhood bipolar disorder: its irritability and impulsivity can also result in disruptive behaviors.
- Conduct disorder: this is the one that must be told apart from oppositional defiant disorder most carefully, and the line is harm. Take a boy of 15 referred for increasing hostility and argumentativeness with his teacher and toward his parents over the last school year, who often loses his temper and blames his classmates when his misbehavior causes him to receive punishment in class, and who had done well previously with his schoolwork. Add to that a history of theft, destruction of property and physical violence toward his peers, and the behavior is now illegal or very harmful, which is conduct disorder rather than oppositional defiant disorder.
Other names offered that do not fit the oppositional pattern are intermittent explosive disorder, dysthymic disorder and mental retardation.