Curriculum · Mental Health / Psychiatry
Psychiatric rating scales and questionnaires
What it is
The scales sit in the psychological limb of the bio psychosocial approach, next to the biological tests and the social assessment. For depression the two named are the Hamilton rating scale for depression and the Beck depression inventory. The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force recommends depression screening for all adolescents 12-18 years of age. The PHQ-2 is a brief screening tool, and a positive result merits further evaluation, which should include a full PHQ-A or a discussion with a qualified clinician. For cognition the named tests are the Confusion Assessment Method (CAM), the Mini-Cog, the Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE), the Montreal Cognitive Assessment test (MoCA) and the Saint Louis University Mental Status exam (SLUMS). Beside them stands the Menopause Rating Scale, which asks about 11 symptoms in three categories, somatic, psychological and urogenital, with a total score that is the sum of each subscale score. In a cross-sectional study of 472 healthy Omani women between 40 and 60 years old, somatic and psychological symptoms occurred more frequently than urogenital symptoms in all three stages: muscle and joint pain was the most common symptom at 73.3%, followed by mental and physical exhaustion at 47.2% and anxiety at 46.6%, and the severity rose with age, with an advanced stage of menopause, and with a lower educational level.
How it is diagnosed
The test is chosen for the question being asked. Where the question is cognition itself, the MMSE screens and does not diagnose: a score below 24 makes dementia possible. The Montreal cognitive assessment is more useful than the MMSE. The scales are only one limb, and the three limbs are not the same from one question to another. In the depression work up the biological limb is CBC, RFT, LFT, TFT, lipid profile and fasting glucose, an ECG, a CT brain if clinically indicated and a urine drug screen; the psychological limb is the Hamilton rating scale for depression and the Beck depression inventory; and the social limb is further exploration of the stressors that may precipitate or perpetuate the illness. In the work up of forgetfulness and confusion the biological limb is CBC, RFT, LFT, TFT, lipid profile and fasting glucose; VDRL and HIV; serum levels of Vit B12 and folate; and, if clinically indicated, a CT scan, an EEG and an LP; the psychological limb is the MMSE and the MoCA; and the social limb is home visits for further assessment of the patient at the community level, such as presence of financial support, safety of the environment, and basic and instrumental activities of daily living. Collateral history is taken first, to gather more information about the symptoms and the extent of the functional impairment. Among the psychological tools, the Mini-Cog is a clock draw with a 3-word recall, the MMSE is the quick bedside screening, and the MoCA is more sensitive, especially early; a CT or MRI brain rules out stroke, NPH and a mass lesion, and the labs to send are B12, TSH, RPR, HIV and CMP.
Before the tests comes the history: the onset, duration and progression of the forgetfulness and confusion; the nature of the forgotten events, remote such as a date of birth against recent such as the place of the keys and other personal items; the associated symptoms of loss of consciousness, fever, seizure and perceptual changes; the mood symptoms and their relationship to the current forgetfulness; the impact on function and the activities of daily living such as bathing, eating and transportation; and any behavioral or perceptual changes. That history is what helps in prioritizing the differential between delirium, dementia and pseudodementia. The two cognitive scales end up inside the Alzheimer diagnosis itself, which is clinical together with the MMSE or MoCA, with MRI showing cortical atrophy of the temporal and parietal lobes. The diagnoses around it are separated by features rather than by score - frontotemporal dementia under 65 years of age, with personality and behaviour change before memory, disinhibition and hyperorality, and frontal or temporal lobe atrophy on MRI; Parkinson disease by its triad of resting tremor, rigidity and bradykinesia; and the Parkinson Plus syndromes by a poor levodopa response, with MSA adding autonomic failure, PSP a vertical gaze palsy, and corticobasal degeneration an asymmetric motor picture with apraxia.