Curriculum · Professionalism and Medical Ethics
The ethical debate on termination of pregnancy
What it is
Abortion is the termination of pregnancy, either spontaneously or intentionally, before the fetus develops sufficiently to survive or before fetal viability. By convention it is usually defined as pregnancy termination prior to 20 weeks' gestation or less than 500-g birthweight.
Therapeutic abortion is the intentional termination of pregnancy for different reasons before 20 weeks gestation.
The lecture divides the ground into three scenarios and takes each on its own: maternal indications, fetal indications, and patient request. Termination of pregnancy became an important concern in the Islamic world, and Muslim scholars have different views regarding the time the spirit is blown into the fetus.
The arguments against
Two lines of argument are set out.
The first turns on innocence: killing people is wrong; killing innocent human beings is wrong; human life begins at conception; therefore the fetus is an innocent human being; therefore killing the fetus is wrong; therefore abortion is always wrong.
The second turns on whether the fetus is a person: a fetus is a person; a fetus has a unique genetic code; a fetus is a unique individual; killing potential people is wrong; it is wrong to destroy potential human life; from conception onwards the fetus is a potential human being; therefore it is wrong to destroy the fetus.
The arguments in favour
The fetus is not necessarily a person with the right to live. A collection of human cells does not have the right to live just because it is of the human species, otherwise amputating a limb would be murder. It has the right to live only by virtue of certain facts: either it has reached a particular stage of development that makes it a moral person, or it possesses certain properties that make it a moral person. Potential human beings do not have rights; only actual human beings have rights.
It is also not always wrong to end the life of an innocent person. There are many cases where we have to choose which of two innocent people will live and which will die: conjoined twins, where the operation to separate them may cause one twin to die; and mountaineering, when one person can only save their own life by cutting the rope supporting a fallen colleague.
The pregnant woman has moral rights too, and under some circumstances these may override the fetus's right to live: the right to ownership of her own body, the right to decide her own future, and the right to take decisions without moral or legal intervention by others. She also has the right to live, so where not aborting the fetus would put the mother's life or health in danger, she has the moral right to abort the fetus.