OmanDocSign in

Curriculum · Professionalism and Medical Ethics

Delivering bad news: the ABCDE and SPIKES protocols

What it is

Bad news should be delivered compassionately and effectively. Five named methods are listed: Rabow and Mc Phee's ABCDE approach, Baile and Buckman's SPIKES approach, the SAAIQ emergency approach from Pakistan, the BREAKS approach by IJPC, and the SAD NEWS approach from Q.U in Canada.

ABCDE: Advance preparation, Build a therapeutic environment, Communicate well, Deal with patient and family reactions, Encourage and validate emotions.

SPIKES stands for: S etting up in privacy; P erceptions of the patient; I nvitation to break news; K nowledge; E motions; S trategy.

SAAIQ: SET the scene as soon as possible; ASSESS the understanding of the attendant; ALERT them that I have bad news; INFORM in clear, understandable words; QUICKLY repeat summary of the situation.

BREAKS stands for: B ackground; R apport; E xplore; A nnounce; K indling; S ummarise.

SAD NEWS: Set up and sit down, Ask don't tell, Deliver the news, No fancy lingo, Expect permit and respond to emotion, Wait, Support and summarise.

Before you start

Advance preparation. Familiarize yourself with all the facts of the case, consultant opinions, prognosis and treatment options. Arrange an appropriate environment and a time where there will be no interruptions, beeper and cell phone among them. Decide who should be there, a relative or a colleague. Mentally rehearse how you will deliver the news, prepare emotionally, and put aside your own personal feelings.

The setting: a quiet room or counseling room with no disturbances; both at eye level and sitting if possible; if the patient is lying, ensure the patient is covered; a comfortable distance; tissues and a phone; the offer of a drink; touch or hold a hand; involve the partner; allow time alone; and be guided by the patient's wishes.

The beginning: introduce yourself, use the patient's name, respect and courtesy, begin with a question, and assess the current emotional state. Listening to the words lets you assess the ability to articulate, and the body language is observed alongside.

Build a therapeutic relationship: determine what the patient wants to know, have family present based upon patient preference, foreshadow the bad news, and assure the patient that you will be available by scheduling a follow-up meeting.