Upper versus lower motor neuron lesions
What it is
The upper motor neuron carries an inhibitory effect on the muscle stretch reflex. The lower motor neuron is the motor component of that same reflex. Lose the first and the reflex is released; lose the second and the reflex is gone.
How it presents
An upper motor neuron lesion gives spastic paralysis, hyperreflexia, hypertonic muscle, disuse atrophy, no fasciculations, a positive Babinski sign, loss of the abdominal and cremasteric reflexes, voluntary movement that is decreased in speed rather than lost, and a large area of the body involved. Tone is read further: decorticate rigidity marks a lesion above the midbrain, decerebrate rigidity a lesion below the midbrain. A lower motor neuron lesion gives weak muscle with decreased tone, decreased deep tendon reflexes, wasting atrophy, fasciculations present, no Babinski sign, voluntary movement lost, and a small area of the body involved. Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis shows both at once, so it is the best case for holding the two side by side: lower motor neuron symptoms are muscle atrophy and fasciculation, from loss of neurons in the anterior horn, and upper motor neuron symptoms are spasticity, hyperreflexia and pathologic reflexes, from degeneration and atrophy of the lateral corticospinal tracts.
How it is diagnosed
Level matters as much as type. In spinal cord compression the upper motor neuron signs occur below the level of the compression, from interruption of the descending corticospinal tracts, while the lower motor neuron signs occur at the level of the lesion, from damage to the anterior horn cells or the nerve roots. The face is the bedside test. With an upper motor neuron lesion the upper face is spared, because both hemispheres contribute to movement of the upper face and the unaffected hemisphere can compensate. With a lower motor neuron lesion the entire face is affected on one side. So facial weakness that includes the forehead is a lower motor neuron sign.