Curriculum · Musculoskeletal / Orthopedic / Rheumatology
Knee ligament injury
What it is
The knee is held by two cruciate ligaments, and either can tear when the joint is injured. An anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) tear happens when the feet stay planted and the upper torso rotates, as when another player collides with a leg that cannot turn with the body. A posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) tear follows a hyperextension injury of the knee. Getting the diagnosis right matters: accurate testing can lead to appropriate referral and treatment for ACL tears, and early detection can lead to better outcomes. The collateral ligaments sit beside the cruciates. The medial collateral is the most commonly injured knee ligament and the lateral collateral the least commonly injured; the tear is seen after a direct blow to the lateral knee, and commonly an ACL or PCL injury goes with it. The posterior cruciate tear is also seen during falls on a flexed knee and in dashboard injuries in motor vehicle accidents.
How it presents
Pain is immediate and severe enough that the injured player is unable to continue the game. Swelling follows, and examination may show a mild knee effusion with painful end ROM. On a knee that has lost one of its cruciate ligaments, the tests below become positive. The anterior cruciate tear presents with a pop in the knee, and the patient may also complain of knee instability or giving way.
How it is diagnosed
The Lachman test is the most accurate test for an ACL tear. It has higher validity, with a sensitivity of 68% for partial ruptures and 96% for complete ruptures. Two other tests are commonly used:
- The anterior drawer test, with a sensitivity of 38% and a specificity of 81%.
- The pivot shift test, which is more technically difficult than the other two and has a sensitivity ranging from 24% to 85%. It is effective if done correctly but should not be used alone to diagnose an ACL tear.
The lever sign test is newer and is easily performed in the office, but sensitivity and specificity reports vary, so it holds promise rather than proof. A positive anterior drawer test together with a positive Lachman test is the pattern of an ACL tear. If instead the posterior drawer test is positive, the damaged structure is the PCL. The McMurray test does not test the ligaments at all; it is used to detect meniscal tears. The Lachman test and the anterior drawer find pathologic anterior tibial translation and can diagnose an ACL tear without imaging, while MRI is most helpful to determine the full extent of the injury. In the posterior cruciate and the collateral tears, X-rays are taken to rule out associated injury or fracture, and MRI is useful for the extent. The McMurray test belongs to the meniscus: the patient supine with the hips flexed 90° and the knee fully flexed, moving the foot into abduction-adduction and external-internal rotation while palpating the joint line for a click; MRI is the standard diagnostic test. Meniscus tears follow acute trauma or, more commonly, degeneration seen with aging; the medial menisci are injured three times more often, and male more than female. In the young patient the tear is likely a purely traumatic tear of the medial meniscus, and in the older patient a degenerative tear of the lateral meniscus is more likely. A loose meniscal fragment may enter the joint space and cause locking, that is inability to extend the knee.
A knee that is tripped and twisted, with immediate swelling and pain, is most likely an anterior cruciate ligament tear even when the examination is limited because of pain and the knee radiograph findings are unremarkable.