Curriculum · Musculoskeletal / Orthopedic / Rheumatology
Principles of fracture reduction and fixation
What it is
Reduction means putting the fracture pieces back in place, and fixation means holding them there. Open reduction is to open at the fracture site, see the fracture pieces with the naked eye, return them and fix them. Closed reduction does not cut the skin: it is manipulation alone, moving the limb to bring the pieces back.
How it is diagnosed
When you are given an x-ray, look for displacement, meaning the fracture pieces are not joining together so the bone is not a straight line, for shortening, meaning an overlap between the bones, and for angulation and rotation. If none of these is present there is no need for reduction, and it is enough to hold the position of the limb until it heals. If any of them is present, move to reduction. Open fractures have their own scheme, the Gustilo classification. Type I is an open fracture with a skin wound under 1 cm in length and clean. Type II is an open fracture with a laceration over 1 cm in length without extensive soft tissue damage, flaps or avulsions. Type III is an open segmental fracture with a wound over 10 cm with extensive soft tissue injury or a traumatic amputation, and gunshot fractures and open fractures caused by farm injuries are special categories within it. Type III is then split three ways. IIIA is adequate soft tissue coverage. IIIB is significant soft tissue loss with exposed bone that requires a soft tissue transfer to achieve coverage. IIIC is an associated vascular injury that requires repair for limb preservation, in which the peripheral artery pulse is absent.
How it is treated
The choice between open and closed depends on the site. Open reduction is used when the fracture is close to a joint, that is peri-articular, for example a tibial plateau fracture at the proximal tibia, an acetabular fracture or an ankle fracture, because the joint has to be restored. Closed reduction suits a fracture away from the articular surface, for example a femoral shaft fracture with angulation, where traction and flexion or extension can bring it back. The management options offered are: closed reduction and cast; closed reduction and an intramedullary nail; closed reduction and fixation with percutaneous k-wires or screws; open reduction and fixation with plates and screws; and open reduction with an external fixator. An elastic nail appears as a further choice in the worked cases. Healing is checked before immobilization is stopped: callus formation on a radiograph and a lack of point tenderness signify adequate healing, and immobilization can then be discontinued. The metatarsal stress fracture shows the pattern in steps: no weight bearing for a few days, possibly with a posterior splint, then a walking boot or short leg cast, then a rigid-soled shoe in 4-6 weeks. The conservative side of it is modified rest for 6-8 weeks with continuation of the activities of daily living and limited walking, with normal activity resumed after 2-3 weeks with no pain, together with NSAIDs, ice, stretching and cross-training. A worked case runs the whole scheme through. A 26 years old male is in a motor vehicle collision with an isolated injury to the left arm, and the x-ray shows angulation, shortening and rotation, so reduction is needed. Because the fracture is away from the joint the reduction is closed, and the fixation is a cast, PoP for 1-2 weeks then changed to a brace to allow joint movement - closed reduction and cast. Humeral fractures are one of the fractures that heal 95% and are rarely operated, which is the reason the case does not go to plates and screws.