Curriculum · Musculoskeletal / Orthopedic / Rheumatology
Open fracture management
What it is
The first question to ask when managing any fracture is whether it is open or closed. An open fracture is a laceration or wound at the site of the fracture or around the area of the fracture; a closed fracture has intact skin. The wound does not have to lie over the broken bone, because when the fracture occurs the skin may be pulled away from the site of fracture, so a radial fracture can carry a wound a little away from the fracture site. The injury is therefore two injuries at once, damaged soft tissue plus broken bone, and both have to be treated.
How it is diagnosed
The Gustilo-Anderson classification rates the degree of the open fracture in three grades, depending on the size of the laceration, which stands for the amount of damaged soft tissue.
- Type I: a clean skin wound under 1 cm with a simple fracture pattern and no skin crushing.
- Type II: a laceration over 1 cm and under 10 cm without extensive soft tissue crushing; the wound bed may appear moderately contaminated.
- Type III: an open segmental fracture, or a single fracture with extensive soft tissue injury over 10 cm. Gunshot fractures and open fractures caused by farm injuries are placed here.
- Type IIIA: adequate soft tissue coverage of the fracture despite high energy trauma or extensive laceration or skin flaps.
- Type IIIB: inadequate soft tissue coverage with periosteal stripping, exposed bone that requires soft tissue transfer to achieve coverage.
- Type IIIC: an open fracture associated with vascular injury that requires repair for limb preservation; the peripheral artery pulse is absent.
With significant soft tissue damage the pulse separates the last two: a palpable dorsalis pedis puts the injury in B, an absent dorsalis pedis in C. B is chosen over A when there is not enough soft tissue for coverage and soft tissue flapping will be needed.
How it is treated
Three lines run together: antibiotics and tetanus to prevent infection, debridement to clean the soft tissue, and fixation to hold the bone. Antibiotics are given within 4 hours of the injury. Type I and type II wounds share one cell: a first generation cephalosporin such as cefazolin for 24 hours. Type III alone takes a first generation cephalosporin for gram +ve organisms, gentamicin for gram -ve organisms, and penicillin when an anaerobic organism is likely, as in a farm injury or bowel contamination, for 24 to 72 hours. Tetanus cover follows the grade and whether the patient is immunized: 1) a non-immunized patient with a type I wound is given tetanus toxoid only; 2) a non-immunized patient with the higher grades is given tetanus toxoid and immunoglobulin; 3) an immunized patient with a type I wound needs no prophylaxis if the booster is less than 10 years old, and a tetanus toxoid vaccine if the booster is older than 10 years; 4) an immunized patient with the higher grades is weighed against 5 years rather than 10, and the table places the answers the other way round — no prophylaxis when the booster is more than 5 years old, and a tetanus toxoid vaccine when it is less than 5 years old. The two rows of the same table disagree, so which way round the rule runs is left open here. Debridement is done in the OR within 24 hours, with low pressure bulb irrigation and normal saline, and repeated every 24 to 48 hours as needed until the wound is ready to be closed. Fixation follows the wound. If the wound is large and cannot be closed, an external fixator is used temporarily until all the soft tissue is cleaned, and the switch is then made to internal fixation; if the wound is small and can be closed, internal fixation is used. Definitive fixation is by plate and screws or by an intramedullary nail. Type IIIB and IIIC start in external fixation, because the soft tissue cannot be closed and debridement has to be repeated until it is clean.