Pleural effusion and Light's criteria
What it is
A pleural effusion is either transudative or exudative, and the rest of the work follows that split. A transudative effusion comes from an imbalance between hydrostatic and oncotic pressures, raised capillary hydrostatic pressure, that is increased capillary wedge pressure, with a fall in capillary oncotic pressure, which increases fluid movement across the capillaries into the visceral pleura and the pleural space. An exudative effusion comes from pleural and lung inflammation with increased capillary and pleural membrane permeability. Transudative fluid requires no further intervention except treatment directed at the underlying disease, while exudative effusions require more extensive diagnostic investigation.
Causes and risk
Common causes of a transudative effusion are congestive heart failure and low protein states. Common causes of an exudative effusion are pulmonary infections, malignancy of pulmonary or metastatic origin, inflammatory conditions such as pancreatitis and autoimmune diseases, injury such as hemothorax and chylothorax, and pulmonary embolism.
How it presents
The characteristic symptoms are dyspnea, pleuritic chest pain and a dry, nonproductive cough, together with symptoms of the underlying disease, such as fever in pneumonia or dyspnea in left-sided heart failure.
Physical exam findings:
- Inspection and palpation: asymmetric expansion and reduced tactile fremitus.
- Auscultation: faint or absent breath sounds, and a pleural friction rub.
- Percussion: dullness over the area of effusion.
How it is diagnosed
Chest x-ray supports the diagnosis with blunting of the costophrenic angle and a meniscus-shaped margin. How much fluid it takes before each sign appears is itself a short list, from the most sensitive down: lateral decubitus picks up more than 10 mL and is the most sensitive; posterior CP angle obliteration takes 75 mL; lateral CP angle obliteration 175 mL; obliteration of the hemidiaphragm 500 mL; and a fluid level at the 4th rib anteriorly more than 1000 mL. A large effusion gives complete opacification of the lung, mediastinal shift, and tracheal deviation away from the effusion, since it behaves as a space-occupying lesion.
Thoracic ultrasound follows an imaging sequence similar to the FAST protocol used for trauma assessment, and shows a hypoechoic or anechoic collection in the lower margins of the pleural cavity, the costodiaphragmatic recess. It is very sensitive and can detect fluid amounts as low as 20 mL. Chest CT is the gold standard, but its use is limited because of radiation and contrast exposure.
Diagnostic thoracentesis is indicated for new unilateral pleural effusions, and for bilateral effusions with atypical features such as fever, chest pain or variable size.
Light's criteria then classify the fluid, and 1 or more of the 3 makes it an exudate: the first, pleural fluid protein over serum protein above 0.5; the second, pleural fluid LDH over serum LDH above 0.6; the third, pleural fluid LDH above 2/3 of the upper limit of normal for serum LDH. Sensitivity is 98% and specificity 83% to detect an exudate. Light's criteria can misclassify a transudative effusion as exudative in about 20% of patients, and two things follow from that: first, the CHF patient after diuresis is the standing example; second, where a borderline exudative effusion is suspected of being transudative, a serum albumin minus pleural albumin gradient above 12 g/L is suggestive of a transudative effusion.
Other clues in the fluid:
- High amylase: esophageal rupture, pancreatitis, malignancy.
- Low glucose: pyogenic infections, malignancy, rheumatoid arthritis. Pleural fluid glucose below 60 mg/dL is usually rheumatoid pleurisy, complicated parapneumonic effusion or empyema, malignant effusion, tuberculous pleurisy, lupus pleuritis, or esophageal rupture; below 30 mg/dL in particular suggests empyema or rheumatic effusion.
- High triglycerides: chylothorax, from traumatic and iatrogenic injuries to the thoracic duct.
- pH below 7.2: given as the hallmark of empyema as against parapneumonic effusion, with positive culturing. The parapneumonic table on another page does not read it that way: it puts pH below 7.20 on the complicated parapneumonic effusion as well as on empyema, and what tells the two apart there is the Gram stain and the culture, negative and usually negative in the complicated effusion, positive and usually positive in empyema.
- Hemorrhagic fluid: hemothorax, post thoracic surgery, malignancy and especially mesothelioma, where atypical cytology is looked for.
Myxedematous, that is hypothyroid, effusions are typically described as transudative but are mostly mixed. In ESRD the effusion is caused either by volume overload, which is transudative, or by uremic inflammation, which is exudative. Meigs' syndrome is pleural effusion with ascites and a benign ovarian mass, a fibroma. The look of the fluid names four of them outright. Empyema is purulent, neutrophil-predominant fluid with a positive Gram stain or culture. Chylothorax is milky white fluid with raised triglycerides. Malignancy shows abnormal cytology. Tuberculosis shows a positive acid-fast bacterium stain or culture. So an effusion whose fluid is milky white with a high triglyceride content is a chylothorax, and not a malignant, tuberculous or empyemic effusion. The pH of the fluid is read against its own ladder. Normal pleural fluid pH is approximately 7.60. Transudative fluid, usually from systemic factors such as increased hydrostatic pressure or hypoalbuminemia, has a pH of 7.4-7.55. Exudate, usually from inflammation, has a pH of 7.30-7.45. A pleural fluid pH below 7.30 with a normal arterial pH and a low pleural glucose is usually from increased acid production by pleural fluid cells and bacteria, as in empyema, or from decreased hydrogen ion efflux from the pleural space, as in pleuritis, tumor or pleural fibrosis.