OmanDocSign in

Curriculum · Cardiovascular and Hypertension

Evaluation of a cardiac murmur

What it is

Timing comes first. Ejection systolic: AS, PS, ASD, HOCM. Pansystolic: VSD, MR, TR. Early diastolic: AR, PR. Mid-diastolic: MS, TS. Continuous, machinery: PDA. Said the other way, systolic heart sounds include aortic and pulmonic stenosis, mitral and tricuspid regurgitation, VSD and MVP; diastolic heart sounds include aortic and pulmonic regurgitation and mitral and tricuspid stenosis. Two mnemonics hold it: MR, TR and VSD are holosystolic — MR. TRiumphed over the VSD; MS and AR are diastolic — MS. ARrested in Diastole.

How it presents

AS: a crescendo then decrescendo ejection murmur at the right 2nd ICS radiating to the carotids, with parvus et tardus, a weak delayed pulse; from calcification in the elderly or a congenital bicuspid valve. MR: blowing holosystolic murmur at the apex, 5th ICS midclavicular line, radiating to the axilla, often with a thrill and a soft S1; an S3 with a soft S1 and a widely split S2 goes with worse MR. TR: blowing holosystolic murmur at the lower left sternal border that increases with inspiration, the Carvallo's sign. AR: decrescendo diastolic murmur at the left sternal border, best heard when the patient leans forward, with bounding pulses, wide pulse pressure, water hammer pulse, the Duroziez sign over the femoral arteries, and an Austin-Flint murmur. MS: opening snap and a low-pitched rumbling diastolic murmur at the apex, in the left lateral decubitus position. MVP: mid-to-late systolic click followed by a late systolic murmur at the apex. Where the murmur radiates is the next thing to note, and three directions carry most of the weight: aortic stenosis radiates to the carotid arteries, mitral regurgitation radiates to the left axilla with the patient in the left lateral recumbent position, and pulmonary stenosis radiates to the interscapular region. So a systolic murmur that radiates to the carotids is read as aortic stenosis, the same timing to the axilla is mitral regurgitation, and to the interscapular region it is pulmonary stenosis. Two more radiate toward the back and should not be taken for those: coarctation of the aorta gives a systolic murmur that is loud in the back, and with upper limb hypertension and a murmur between the scapulae the first answer is coarctation, while PDA gives a continuous murmur that can also radiate toward the back. Congenital lesions have their own murmur map, and what sits beside the murmur is what settles it:

How it is diagnosed

Maneuvers tell them apart. Inspiration makes right sided murmurs louder, expiration makes left sided murmurs louder. MS, MR, AS and AR increase with expiration, squat and leg raise, and decrease with standing and Valsalva. HOCM and the MVP murmur do the opposite: they increase with standing and Valsalva and decrease with expiration, squat and leg raise. The MVP click does the opposite of its own murmur — on standing the murmur increases while the click decreases, and on squatting the murmur decreases while the click increases. The same maneuvers are also set out as a change in timing rather than in intensity: hand grip, which increases afterload, gives MVP a later onset of click and murmur; Valsalva phase II and standing up, which decrease preload, give it an earlier onset of click and murmur; and rapid squatting, which increases venous return, preload and afterload, gives it a later onset again. Handgrip increases afterload and so increases the intensity of MR, AR and VSD murmurs, and decreases the hypertrophic cardiomyopathy murmur. Valsalva and standing up decrease preload, decreasing the intensity of most murmurs including AS, and increasing the hypertrophic cardiomyopathy murmur. When a systolic murmur raises the question of aortic stenosis, four others are told apart from it by their differentiating features. Aortic valve sclerosis of the elderly, without stenosis: the systolic murmur does not peak late, the carotids do not have delayed upstrokes, and there is no left ventricular hypertrophy by EKG. Hypertrophic obstructive cardiomyopathy: brisk bifid carotid upstrokes, a murmur that usually does not radiate into the neck, and a pseudoinfarct pattern with large septal Q waves on EKG. Mitral regurgitation: the murmur is holosystolic and radiates to the axilla and not the carotids, the carotid upstroke may be normal, and the left ventricle is dilated. Pulmonic stenosis: the murmur does not radiate into the neck, is loudest along the left sternal border, and increases with inspiration, and the chest x-ray and EKG may reveal an enlarged right ventricle. In a child, the 3 S for innocent murmurs: aSymptomatic patient, Soft blowing murmur, Systolic murmur only and not diastolic, left Sternal edge. The examination itself has an order to it. Look at the precordium for surgical scars: a midline sternotomy scar, or a thoracotomy scar for mitral valvotomy, which may be missed under the female breast. Feel the apex beat for position and character, then feel for a left parasternal heave and for thrills at the apex and on either side of the sternum. Palpate the right carotid pulse while listening, so that the cardiac events are timed. Always comment on the first and second heart sounds, and mention any additional heart sounds. With the diaphragm, listen at the apex, below the sternum, along the left sternal edge, at the second right intercostal space and at the neck, for the ejection systolic murmur of aortic stenosis or aortic sclerosis. If the mid-diastolic murmur of mitral stenosis is not heard, listen at the apex in the left lateral position with the bell, on expiration. For the early diastolic murmur of aortic regurgitation, sit the patient forward and listen with the diaphragm along the left sternal edge in the 3rd intercostal area with the breath held in expiration. If a murmur is heard at the apex, have the patient breathe in and out to bring out the variation in intensity with respiration; if it is pansystolic, listen at the axilla. Then, away from the precordium: the lung bases for signs of cardiac failure, sacral and leg oedema, the liver, tender in cardiac failure, splenomegaly for endocarditis, the blood pressure, and the peripheral pulses with radiofemoral delay.